Question
Atualizado em
Vova83
3 fev 2018

  • Russo
  • Ucraniano
  • Inglês (EUA)
  • Inglês (Reino Unido)
Pergunta sobre Inglês (Reino Unido)

Qual é a diferença entre I lived in London e I've lived in London e I used to live in London ?Você pode indicar exemplo de resposta.

Respostas
Ler mais comentários
dianat98
3 fev 2018

  • Polonês

I lived - You lived once for example 5 years ago and now you don't live there
I've lived - it has an influence or effect on your life now for example "I've lived in London so I know English very good"

0 likes
poesiadautunno
3 fev 2018

  • Italiano

i lived =the action is ended
i have lived = i lived there and i still live there
i used to live = habitual action in the past. i lived there when i was a child but now i don't live there anymore

Vova83
4 fev 2018

  • Russo
  • Ucraniano
@poesiadautunno "i have lived = i lived there and i still live there" is not correct. "I've lived" talk only about experience.
i have lived for (since)... = I lived there and i still live there
I need native speaker answer
0 likes
Usuário excluído
4 fev 2018

@Vova83: "He lived in London" implies he lived in London sometime in the past, but it's NOT KNOWN whether he still lived in London after that time or whether he still lives in London now. For example, if someone says "He lived in London in 2012", then it's UNCERTAIN whether he still lived in London after 2012 or whether he still lives in London now. The speaker may lost contact with him after 2012, so the speaker does NOT know where he lived after 2012. If you say "I lived in London in 2012", the other person will think that you LEFT London after 2012, since you always know where you live. However, the other person still does NOT know whether you live in London now, because you may go on to say that you left London after 2012 but came back in 2015 and stayed in London from your arrival until now, so you still lives in London now. You may also left London after 2012 and do not live there any more after your departure. (Departure is the act of leaving a place.) "I've lived in London" implies that you began living in London at sometime in the past and you STAYED in London from that time until now, so you STILL lives in London now. For example, "I've lived in London for 3 years" implies that you began living in London 3 years ago and stayed in London from that time until now. "I've lived in London since 2012" implies that you began living in London in 2012 and stayed in London from 2012 until now. "I used to live in London" implies that you lived in London at sometime in the PAST, but you left London after that and have stayed OUTSIDE of London since your departure, so you do NOT live in London any more. For example, if you say "I used to live in London in 2012", then you left London after 2012 and have stayed OUTSIDE of London since your departure, so you do NOT live in London any more after 2012. In short, if you say "I lived in London", then whether you live in London now is UNCERTAIN. (You may or may NOT live in London now.) If you say "I've lived in London", then it's CLEAR that you STILL LIVES in London now. If you say "I used to live in London", then you do NOT live in London any more.

@Vova83: "He lived in London" implies he lived in London sometime in the past, but it's NOT KNOWN whether he still lived in London after that time or whether he still lives in London now. For example, if someone says "He lived in London in 2012", then it's UNCERTAIN whether he still lived in London after 2012 or whether he still lives in London now. The speaker may lost contact with him after 2012, so the speaker does NOT know where he lived after 2012.

If you say "I lived in London in 2012", the other person will think that you LEFT London after 2012, since you always know where you live. However, the other person still does NOT know whether you live in London now, because you may go on to say that you left London after 2012 but came back in 2015 and stayed in London from your arrival until now, so you still lives in London now. You may also left London after 2012 and do not live there any more after your departure. (Departure is the act of leaving a place.)

"I've lived in London" implies that you began living in London at sometime in the past and you STAYED in London from that time until now, so you STILL lives in London now. For example, "I've lived in London for 3 years" implies that you began living in London 3 years ago and stayed in London from that time until now. "I've lived in London since 2012" implies that you began living in London in 2012 and stayed in London from 2012 until now.

"I used to live in London" implies that you lived in London at sometime in the PAST, but you left London after that and have stayed OUTSIDE of London since your departure, so you do NOT live in London any more. For example, if you say "I used to live in London in 2012", then you left London after 2012 and have stayed OUTSIDE of London since your departure, so you do NOT live in London any more after 2012.

In short, if you say "I lived in London", then whether you live in London now is UNCERTAIN. (You may or may NOT live in London now.) If you say "I've lived in London", then it's CLEAR that you STILL LIVES in London now. If you say "I used to live in London", then you do NOT live in London any more.

Usuário excluído
4 fev 2018

@Vova83: "I have lived = I lived there and I still live there" is correct.

Vova83
4 fev 2018

  • Russo
  • Ucraniano
@aussibienque Thanks. It's very good explanation.
Vova83
4 fev 2018

  • Russo
  • Ucraniano
@aussibienque But how should I say about just an experience of living in London, no matter I live now or not?
0 likes
poesiadautunno
4 fev 2018

  • Italiano

@Vova83 i meant i heve lived there for or since.... as the sentence suggested

0 likes
Usuário excluído
10 fev 2018

@Vova83: Just say "I lived in London". You can also add some past time after "London", such as "I lived in London in 2012" and "I lived in London from 2010 to 2013". All these sentences can be used regardless of whether or not you live in London now.

[Notícias] Ei você! Aquele que está aprendendo um idioma!

Você sabe como melhorar suas habilidades no idioma❓ Tudo o que você precisa fazer é ter sua escrita corrigida por um falante nativo!
Com a HiNative, você pode ter sua escrita corrigida por falantes nativos gratuitamente ✍️✨.
Registar
Compartilhe esta pergunta
Qual é a diferença entre I lived in London e I've lived in London e I used to live in London ?
Problemas semelhantes
Problemas semelhantes
Trending questions
Newest Questions
Pergunta anterior/Próxima pergunta

Pergunte a falantes nativos gratuitamente

Inscreva-se grátis
hinative app preview balloon background image flying monga
  1. HiNative
  2. L
  3. Lo
  4. London
  5. Qual é a diferença entr...